RubricMark · Sample questions · Interactive samples

Assignment feedback example — persuasive writing report

High school English · Unit 4 · Fictional Year 10 essay · quote-anchored deductions · learner-verifiable report

Public sample assignment feedback report with criterion-level marks and manuscript quotes for each deduction — not generic AI grader copy.

Every deduction below links to a manuscript excerpt so you can verify the feedback.

Persuasive essay — Student A (anonymized demo)

MARKING REPORT · DRAFT · Year 10 English · persuasive assignment

Total score

31 / 40 · 78%

Summary feedback

A clear argument with solid structure. Strengthen evidence integration with sourced quotes and tighten the conclusion so it restates the thesis without new ideas.

Strengths

Verified against quotes from the manuscript.

Criterion-level feedback

8 / 10 Thesis and argument

Thesis is explicit and mostly sustained. Paragraph 3 drifts from the central claim.

Quote-anchored deduction: −2 · Body paragraph does not support the main thesis.

Manuscript quote“However, many people still disagree about this issue.”Paragraph 3
7 / 10 Evidence and analysis

Uses one strong statistic but analysis of how it supports the claim is thin.

Quote-anchored deduction: −3 · Limited explanation of how evidence supports the claim.

Manuscript quote“Recycling rates have improved in many cities across the country.”Page 2 · no source cited
9 / 10 Structure and cohesion

Introduction, body, and conclusion are well signposted with effective transitions.

7 / 10 Language and mechanics

Generally fluent formal tone; several comma splices reduce clarity.

Quote-anchored deduction: −3 · Repeated comma splices.

Manuscript quote“Phones are useful, they help students research, this is important.”Paragraph 4